I stood in line for Walk The Line
Sunday, February 26th, 2006I’ve now seen two of the 5 flicks nominated for Best Picture: Brokeback Mountain and Walk The Line.
When A and I saw Brokeback Mountain a few weeks ago, our friends had strongly promoted the film as a must-see, but we left the movie feeling a bit let down. Of course, it IS a pretty depressing story and in that way can’t compare to Walk The Line. Brokeback Mountain just didn’t grab us.
Yet, they are both nominated for Best Picture. Based upon what criteria does a film get nominated for Best Picture of the Year? Supposedly the films are judged on the movie-making quality. I suspect that many academy members vote based on what they like, not necessarily quality. Now, I’ve never made a movie and I am not in the industry. But I do know what I like and don’t like.
I greatly enjoyed Walk The Line. It was a good story. JR Cash endured a difficult childhood. His ambition to become a singer/songwriter got him into the music business. Access to pills and the touring musician’s lifestyle fostered his addiction. He and June Carter, both married, fall in love. And he makes his comeback performance at Folsom Prison!
Joaquin Phoenix’s performance was strong, fervent, irresistible and mighty. Reese Witherspoon was equally exciting, fierce and passionate in her performance. The characters that both played were potent people.
I loved seeing June Carter stand up to Johnny Cash, give him hell when it was due him. And that seemed to be the case quite a bit.
Walk The Line doesn’t pull its punches in telling the story of these two great country musicians. Meanwhile, Brokeback Mountain was a story of repressed, hidden love. Both were well-told. I had a stronger, emotional response to Walk The Line.
Witherspoon and Phoenix are awesome and Walk The Line is a powerful and meaningful movie.







